From the TUC

An increased role for Strong Unions can end unpaid intern exploitation

24 Sep 2013, By

This is a version of my contribution to the Unions21 & Intern Aware Labour Conference fringe on ‘How Labour can end unpaid internships’.

I’d like to start by paying tribute to the work of Intern Aware. They’ve maintained the profile of this important issue and assembled a coalition of supporters that has increased the effectiveness of the campaign. They’ve also contributed to the policy debate on how to end this exploitative practice. Not bad for two part timers!!!

I want to make three points in my contribution.

The first is that I worry that the continued use of unpaid interns is a symptom of what might be described as an ‘epidemic of exploitation’ of young people. As a society, we are in danger, of exploiting their ambition and even their desperation to find work and get on in life.

A depressing survival of the fittest mentality underpins the whole practice of unpaid internships.

The message appears to be that longer you are prepared (or forced) to work with no pay the greater the chance you’ll have of finding a job eventually.

And of course that principle has underpinned elements of the governments workfare programme.

The most perverse element of which is that many young people, forced into compulsory so-called work experience, have been prevented from looking for more permanent, decent work.

The debate on how to end unpaid internships is most often based on two elements.

Increased legal protections for individuals – usually around how a worker is defined – and increased enforcement by government agencies.

The TUC supports any attempt to improve the resources available to HMRC to enforce the minimum wage.

We support the naming and shaming of, and increased fines for, employers who exploit young people.

And of course we support any improvement in the suite of employment rights enjoyed by individual workers.

But the second point I’d like to make is that individual rights – and even a beefed up enforcement of the NMW – wont on their own be enough to end the scourge of unpaid internships.

Indeed we must remember that unpaid internships – where the intern can be classified as a worker (and let’s remember that’s most if not all of them) – are already illegal.

Rights that apply to individual workers, whilst of course important, are diminished in value if they arent accompanied with the opportunity to enforce them

And to enforce them collectively and in real time rather than just retrospectively and (given the governments introduction of employment tribunal fees) expensively.

The limits of enforcement by individuals and government agencies are all too apparent.

There have been just two attempted NMW prosecutions and individual successes by individual unpaid interns are so rare that amongst us here today we could probably name the interns who have been successful in recovering unpaid wages.

That is not a criticism of anyone, rather a reflection on the extent to which the system is stacked – both legally and practically – against individuals.

It’s also important to remember that this is a structural problem. The use of unpaid interns is endemic in many industries.

Many have business models that rely on a constant supply of unpaid labour.

Frankly, I’m unconvinced that employers can be left alone to address the issue and won’t still try to find loopholes and exploit vagaries in the definition of who is and isn’t a worker.

A structural problem therefore requires a more fundamental remedy.

So, wouldn’t it be great if a force existed in society with a proven record of being able to improve terms, conditions and enforce employment rights via collective representation and negotiation?

And wouldn’t it be good if this was achieved in the main by volunteer workplace representatives who provide their colleagues with individual and collective support and representation in the workplace?

And wouldn’t it be brilliant if such organisations already existed?

I think we’d agree that any government, particularly a Labour government, serious about fairness at work should be enthusiastic about such organisations playing an increased role in society.

And that to enable such organisations to realise their full potential, would be concerned with giving them a fairer chance to extend and assert their role and influence to the scale required if they are to act as a counter balance to the power and influence that global corporations have over not just individual workers but also government.

Our trade union movement has for generations been the most consistent force for good in society concerned with the improvement of life at work.

Every day, unions and our 200,000 union reps, make our workplaces safer!

Every day they give workers access to learning and training opportunities – the chance to reach their potential!

Every day they give personal representation – mitigation and advocacy, advice and guidance – to thousands of workers!

So my third and final point is that whatever discussion takes place this week about the role of unions IN the Labour Party, let’s make sure the party has the confidence to assert and discuss how we can extend the benefits and influence of trade unions IN THE WORKPLACE.

It’s no coincidence that the UK, as well as being amongst those countries in the EU with the highest rates of inequality is also amongst those with the lowest collective bargaining coverage.

It’s no coincidence that as union density has declined, the share of the nation’s wealth that goes to wages has declined as well and that the proportion of the nation’s wealth that has gone to the top 1% has increased significantly.

And I don’t believe that it’s entirely a coincidence that in some of the industries where the use of unpaid interns is most prevalent, union organisation is weak.

We in the trade union movement have to find some of the solutions to these organisational challenges ourselves.

We have to increase the resources we devote to organising and have to be more innovative and creative in thinking about we appeal to young workers and creating structures that make participation appealing, practical and effective.

But the time has surely also come to re-establish that all too brief post war consensus that saw unions as legitimate and valued participants in society.

I have limited expectations of the party that meets next week in Manchester but I set the bar high for Labour.

The potential for an expanded union role in ending exploitation in workplaces beyond those where they have recognition as narrowly defined under existing legislation is significant.

But the benefits for individual workers and society in general will be great.

7 Responses to An increased role for Strong Unions can end unpaid intern exploitation

  1. Garry from Berkshire
    Sep 24th 2013, 8:19 pm

    Since the 1980s onwards the unions have been stripped of influence by both conservative and labour governments.This has left the field clear for bad employers to bully vulnerable workers and make life uncertain for all workers whether they be young or old.
    Unions must strive to win back their place in society so they can play a much greater role in protecting the British workforce.

  2. ?????? ??? ?? 2011
    Oct 18th 2013, 4:42 am

    Some yrs in the past, Mountain State politicians jumped with a nationwide bandwagon and began presenting fat tax credits for people who get automobiles that operate on “alternative fuels.” For anyone who is available in the market for an electric automotive which could be recharged in the outlet into your garage, you’re in luck: The point out will provide you with a tax credit rating of just as much as $7,five hundred for purchasing one.
    ?????? ??? ?? 2011

  3. Louis Vuitton ?? ???
    Oct 18th 2013, 4:42 am

    2) Studying tips on how to manage is finished even while engaged on actual concerns and problems.
    Louis Vuitton ?? ???

  4. Louis Vuitton ?? ????
    Oct 18th 2013, 4:43 am

    five Things To complete This Weekend, July 1214: Roots, boots and massive suitsDAVID FARMER
    Louis Vuitton ?? ????

  5. ?????? ??? ??
    Oct 18th 2013, 4:43 am

    Following that, it had been goldrush time with the financial commitment and commercial banking industry. Ever more enormous distributions of collateralized property finance loan derivatives have been done. stock and bond markets.
    ?????? ??? ??

  6. ?????? ?? 2013 ?????
    Oct 18th 2013, 4:44 am

    Even if there may be no speedy indication of relief towards persistent loadshedding predicament that afflicts the full state, there may be at least an indication the do the job within the new government is experiencing an impression. Of their endeavours to have what the heck is stemming from them a variety of Unbiased Power Producers (IPPs) had filed circumstances in opposition to the earlier government. On Friday they placed on the apex courtroom with the withdrawal within the circumstances, as well as courtroom has questioned for any copy within the Memorandum of Comprehending (MoU) which has been signed around the IPPs as well as government. The excellent news tends to be that the IPPs have agreed to supply additional potential while in Ramazan at the same time as extending the credit score time period from thirty to 60 days regarding payment of remarkable dues, a move that’s about to ‘unblock’ the logjam and have potential on the wires again.
    ?????? ?? 2013 ?????

  7. ?????? ???? ???
    Oct 18th 2013, 4:44 am

    In “Wall Street’s Give attention to Florida:”Robert Heller, CEO, Spectrum Gaming Cash, moderates;Christopher E. Jones, director, Telsey Advisory Group LLC; Gregory Roselli, govt director, Credit score Preset Source of income, Gaming Lodging Leisure, UBS Securities LLC; Carlo Santarelli, director, Deutsche Financial institution Securities Inc., Gaming Lodging Research; Joel Simkins, director senior gaming, lodging and leisure analyst, Credit score Suisse
    ?????? ???? ???